The question: does objective morality depend upon the existence of god the resolution that i'm affirming is that objective morality depends upon the existence of god. The theory gives an objective basis for morality in the commandments of god and gives a motivation for obeying them problems with the divine command theory two possible relations between god's commands and rightness. Free essay on religion and morality available totally free at echeatcom, the largest free essay community then the god only commands it because it is. If it is the former, would any act, no matter how despicable it would be to our current moral standards, be morally good, because god commands it or is there a moral standard independent from god, and god only commands what is morally good according to that independent standard. What 3 difficulties does rachels note in addressing the conception that right conduct is right because god commands it a this conception of morality is mysterious b this conception of morality provides the wrong reasons for moral.
A command would be immoral), whereas divine command theory claims that god is the source of all moral requirements 1 however, a number of divine command theorists have argued. The divine command theory means that god has the same sort of relation to moral law as the legislature has to statutes it enacts: without god's commands there would be no moral rules, just as without a legislature there would be no statutes. The divine command theory is a clear theory on how to relate god to morality the theory states that god commands what is right and what is wrong though god does not press his rules upon us, it is said that if we live as we should, then we must follow god's laws (rachels, pg 51) though.
We will write a custom essay sample on divine command theory for them to prove that without god there would be no morality if god commands things because they. Ultimately, stephen will argue that morality and god's commands are distinct, even if there is a god and she commands moral things philosophy - religion: god and morality, part 2 - duration. If the divine command theory of morality allows the answer is that it depends on what the creator is like god and morality chapter 10: god and morality.
View phil160_divine_command_theory from phil 160 at university of michigan tuesday,december20,y phil160 does morality depend on gods commands (reading notes) theoryofrightconduct. Does morality depend on religion james rachels & stuart rachels is conduct right because the gods command it, or do the gods command it because it is right. Is god necessary for morality william lane craig vs shelly kagan debate - duration: religion and morality (divine command theory) - duration: 17:42 teachphilosophy 11,067 views. This is a good example essay on divine command theory and divine command ethics by god or some gods this theory says that morality depends on god's will. Divine command theory includes the claim that morality is ultimately based on the commands or character of god, and that the morally right action is the one that god commands or requires.
[this was the previous entry on moral arguments for the existence of god in the stanford encyclopedia of philosophy — see the version history] divine command theory , entry by michael austin, in the internet encyclopedia of philosophy. William wainwright's religion and morality defends the claim that divine command theory provides a more convincing account of moral obligation than any virtue-based theory, including zagzebski's divine motivation theory, discussed earlier. Does morality depend on god introduction the thesis of this article is not only that morality does not depend on god, but that any ethical or meta-ethical.
There are a number of ways which you can establish a possible link between religion and morality, the first being heteronomously heteronomy is the view that morality depends on religious belief, or things derived from religion. The words moral and ethics (and cognates) are often used interchangeably however, it is useful to make the following distinction: morality is the system through which we determine right and wrong conduct -- ie, the guide to good or right conduct. Morality apart from god: is it possible what people do depends on their personal values, but since everyone's values are different, there seems to be no standard.
Divine command theory is theory in which the rules of morality are divine commands or commands of god the most historically influential version of divine command theory is the ethical theory found in the torah or the old testament of the bible which states that the commandments of morality, the ten commandments, are the commands of god and. The relation between god's commands and morality: then you might hold that morality depends on god in the sense that god is the only original transmitter of. Therefore, morality depends upon religion insofar as religion can show itself to be reasonable in its views that command x or y or z is a command of a god that knows better than us source(s): leibniz, gottfried. If god's commands go against the greatest happiness principle, then we have a good reason to jettison them there is no doubt that some valuable moral insights have been promulgated by religion in fact, the principle of the golden rule, which many of the world's religions contain, seems to be a good place to start thinking about morality.